- Sorry figure
May 4, 2013
The end to extreme poverty might very well be within reach. But is the bar too low?
- A rubbernecking ride
April 27, 2013
One of the best ways to do Chi town is a river ride though you may get a crick in your neck trying to catch a glimpse of all the historic and modern…
- Stone on Clinton
April 20, 2013
If Hilary Clinton decides to run for President in 2016, one Hollywood star who won't be cheering is director Oliver Stone.
- In This Section
- Entire Website
From the Times Of India
- MOST POPULAR
Door out of Dhaka
Pre-Partition, Hindus in Bangladesh constituted 28 per cent of the population. Their numbers have been steadily declining since then. Most of this drastic demographic shift was during the Partition and the two decades of East Pakistan, claims Dhaka. Yet, the minority in the country that Sheikh Mujibur Rahman built has a different story to tell.
Are Hindus in Bangladesh quietly giving up on their country? Has the deep brotherhood forged by a shared language, culture and history caved in? Is the country's biggest minority group being forced to migrate in large numbers due to persecution ? Though no one can deny that the Hindu population of Bangladesh has been slowly declining over the years since it got independence from Pakistan, questions of how much it has declined and why it has happened generates heated debate among both the communities, Muslims and Hindus.
According to the census website of Bangladesh, in 2001, Hindus were 9. 6 per cent of the population. Most blogs and websites devoted to the status of the Hindu minority in Bangladesh contrast this with the 28 per cent that once existed there. But they don't take into account the fact that this was the pre-Partition figure, calculated during the 1941 census. Soon after Partition in 1947, millions of Hindus fled to India.
In the census after the Partition exodus, in 1951, the Hindu population had already fallen to 22 per cent and this again fell to 18. 5 per cent by the 1961 census. "During the Bangladesh Liberation War of 1971, Hindus in particular bore the brunt of the Pakistan army's onslaught, leading to more migration, " a Bangladesh government official told TOI-Crest. "Though many returned after the formation of Bangladesh, the 1974 census showed that the population had fallen to 13. 5 per cent, mostly because of steady emigration to Burma and India. Obviously, since Bangladeshi independence, the Hindu population has not fallen as much as is being claimed. Bangladeshis cannot be held responsible for what happened even before they became an independent country."
Rabindranath Trivedi, president of the Human Rights Congress for Bangladesh Minorities (HRCBM), has a different take altogether. According to Trivedi, the census was deliberately undercounting Hindus in Bangladesh, who, by his estimate, constitute about 15 per cent of the population even today. "The government does this on purpose to deflect the charge of large scale Hindu migration due to state oppression, " he said. "With a low percentage to start off with, there can be no declining population due to migration. In reality, there is continuous migration of Hindus from Bangladesh because of torture and humiliation. "
But there are other, equally compelling, reasons for the demographic shift. India's long and porous borders with Bangladesh, old family ties and ethnic similarity coupled with better economic opportunities have resulted in continuous illegal migration of poor Hindus and - not to forget - a considerable number of Muslims. In fact, the home ministry concedes its inability to fix a number to the volume of Bangladeshi Muslim immigrants coming into India. "India being economically better off, it is the natural destination for the poor, both Hindus and Muslims, " explained a Bangladeshi official. "A lot of migration is on economic grounds rather than due to any persecution. "
Government officials and civil society leaders further argue that violence against religious minorities comes with its share of political and economic undertones rather than purely religious ones. "It suits those who have fled to India to make the situation seem worse for Hindus in Bangladesh than what it is. This helps justify their fleeing and seeking refuge in India, " one of them said.
Farid Hossain, journalist and social commentator, who accepts that Hindus don't have it easy in Bangladesh, said, "Hindus perceived to be supporters of the Awami League become opposition party targets, especially at the time of elections. No matter who wins or loses, Hindus are the target of violence. But as even stray incidents of violence against Hindus are widely reported, it adds to their sense of insecurity. This, in turn, affects their sense of belonging and induces them to leave. "
International rights bodies such as Amnesty International and UNHCR, too, have repeatedly castigated the Bangladesh government for its treatment of minorities. Even the United States Commission on International Religious Freedom (USCIRF) slammed Dhaka in 2006 for continuous persecution of minority Hindus.
Historically, though, Bangladesh was founded as a secular republic in 1971. However, Islam was declared the state religion after the military takeover in the 1980s. The constitution, of course, guarantees the right to practise and propagate all religions.
Bimal Pramanik, director of the Centre for Research in Indo-Bangladesh Relations, Kolkata, said, "Bengalis fought communal forces to fight for independence as a Bengali nation. There was only one identity, that of a Bengali. But after the assassination of
Sheikh Mujibur Rehman and the army takeover, total Islamisation started and the Hindus felt betrayed. "
While freedom of religion might be publicly supported by the government, all international reports observe that attacks on religious and ethnic minorities are an unremitting problem. Almost all the reports refer to numerous instances of illegal land seizures, arson, extortion, sexual assault and intimidation of religious minorities, particularly Hindus. Most of these refer not only to the 1990s, but also to the period when the BNP led by Khaleda Zia shared power with Islamist parties during 2001-06, a time when the country witnessed an unprecedented rise in religious intolerance.
After the Awami League's victory in 2008, Sheikh Hasina came to power and initiated steps to secure the rights of minorities. International bodies have since then been more positive about Bangladesh's efforts to protect minorities. This even as one of the most vexatious of issues, land grabbing, continues unaddressed.
Professor Abul Barkat of Dhaka University's Department of Economics, in his survey on the status of Hindus since independence, found that the Vested Property Act was the single largest cause of migration of Hindus from Bangladesh. The law, which allowed the government to possess property abandoned by those who fled during Partition, soon metamorphosed into something abused by both citizens and the state.
The study found that 2. 01 million acres, comprising 45 per cent of the land owned by Hindus, was lost due to this Act. Though there were attempts to amend the law, little has changed. Sustained campaigning on the issue led to the Awami League government passing the Vested Property Return Act 2001. But this law to return appropriated land is caught in bureaucratic and legal tangles. "When it comes to land, there is no secularism. All parties have been involved in land grabbing and no one is keen on implementing this law, " Hossain said.
Faced with charges of persecuting minorities, the pomp and peaceful conduct of Hindu festivals like Durga Puja and Saraswati puja are often held up by the government as examples of religious tolerance and proof of the rule of law. But Trivedi has a counter view. "Muslims, too, participate in our festivals, " he said. "But that is because it is part of their culture as Bengalis. Hence, even if the last Hindu leaves this country, Muslims will continue to celebrate the festivals. "
Many Hindus see the Pujas more as a sort of dole and appeasement of minorities, seeing no hope for real improvement in their status. "The persecution will continue till the last Hindu is driven out. Hindus will become objects in a museum, a people who once inhabited this land, " Trivedi said. Pramanik agrees. "Despite all efforts of the Awami League to undo the damage done to Bangladeshi society from decades of Islamisation, it just might be a case of too little too late, " he said.
Register for Full Access to the Crest Edition
Don't have a Facebook Account? Sign up for Times Crest here.